Ram Setu: Myth or Truth?
Pratyush , New Delhi: Sep 12 2007
Made Popular Sep 12 2007
India :

Ram Setu: Myth or Truth?

Was there any Setu (Bridge) or not? If yes, is that Setu natural or man-made? There are so many questions regarding the existence of the Setu, what saffron leaders call as Ram Setu. BJP, VHP claim that the Setusamudram project, proposed by the government of India, would destroy the mythical ‘Ram Setu’ connecting India to Sri Lanka.

The Sethusamudram Project proposes linking the Palk Bay and the Gulf of Mannar between India and Sri Lanka by creating a shipping canal. The logic behind making the canal that it would provide a continuous navigable sea route around the peninsula.

On the other hand, saffron parties such as the BJP and the VHP have opposed the government proposed project with the logic that it would destroy the Ram Setu or Lord Rama’s celebrated path of rocks to ancient Lanka.

Some people, who favored the Sethusamudram project, said that the sand and bars at the bottom of the straits are actually a natural phenomenon. This may not be a man-made structure.

While, the Archeological Survey of India (ASI) has informed the Supreme Court the story of the existence of any man-made bridge is baseless and not scientifically established anymore. There is no any evidence that the bridge was built by Lord Ram’s monkey army or the events of the Ramayana ever had happened.

The ASI later said that it couldn’t declare Ram Setu as national monument because of no established scientific evidence that might prove the existence of the characters or the events of the Ramayana.
Ram Setu: Myth or Truth?

It said that the Ram Setu is not a man made structure but just a natural formation of sand. On the other hand, the BJP blamed the UPA government of blasphemy when the ASI told SC that there was no historical evidence of the existence of Ram Setu.

BJP leader Vijay Kumar Malhotra said:

This is sheer blasphemy. It’s an insult to the Hindu faith. We also wonder why Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Congress chief Sonia Gandhi have been going for the Dussehra festival if their government does not believe in Lord Ram’s existence.

Today, the government, in its affidavit, says there is no evidence to prove Lord Rama built the bridge or that Lord Ram ever existed. This is an attack on Hindu sentiments, a ferocious one.

The BJP and the VHP have strongly opposed the Sethusamudram project by saying that it would be dangerous for the undersea bridge that was believed to be built by monkey army of Lord Ram.

On Wednesday, Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) activists stooped the daily traffic movement and railways movement across the country. They had some clash with the police at many places.

They protested against the government’s statement made before the court and questioning the existence on the authenticity of the Ramayan events. They had called the blockage for three-hour in many parts of Mumbai, Delhi, north and northwest India just to register their protest against the Sethusamudram Shipping Canal project.
Ram Setu: Myth or Truth?

BJP Leader ID Swami warned the UPA of dire consequences and said:

This agitation is a warning to the UPA; if the Government doesn’t listen the results will be dangerous. Hindus are opposed to the demolition of Ram Setu. The ’sacred Setu’ should not be touched, as it is associated with sentiments of Hindus.

The Supreme Court has asked the centre to stop all the construction works of dredging in the Ram Setu region to build the canal proposed under the Sethusamudram project till the next date of hearing. The SC has decided to hear the matter on Friday.

Some believed facts about the Ram Setu-


# Ram Setu is a mythical bridge existed southeast of Rameshwaram, Tamil Nadu that links India with the Talaimanar coast of Sri Lanka.

# Rs 2087-crore Sethusamudram project would build a canal that would go from the west coast of India to the east coast without circling Sri Lankan territory. Hindu Brigade say that the project would damage the Ram Setu.

#
The work on the project has been started since July 2005.

# According to Hindu mythology, Lord Ram’s monkey army had built the Ram Setu to cross over to Sri Lanka to rescue Sita.

#
The UPA Government says the Setu is actually a natural built by 30-km-long chain of sand banks.

# The Supreme Court has stopped the government from continuing any construction work in the project till further hearing.

# The Sethusamudram Ship Canal Project would reduce the trip of sea between India and Sri Lanka and would cut costs for freight traffic.

Read

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Manual Upload
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Shankar
Jaipur, India
Lord Ram? Ram Temple? Ramayan? Ram Setu? What are you talking about? What is that and why is that? Is it something where Hindu prays? Which god? The one which scientifically doesn’t exist!

We need to get proof (scientifically and historically proved) from the so-called secular political leaders and politics-affected government officials before offering any prayer to the Gods exist in our religious belief.

We should make something useful and economically viable or a church/mosque in place of Hindu Temples. Some of the political parties are always ready to do something like that because they can do anything to get the power in Indian democracy. I think Congress will do that. I would say just shame on you leaders.

Pratyush, you covered this news better than any other newspaper I gone through. Keep it up.
0 Stars
Ramasamy
Sydney, Australia
Let us believe in truth, by not getting carried away by emotions and sentiments. It is true that Hindus always claimed history by myths, vandalism, sentiments or emotions, but these necessarily doesn’t constitute any truth keeping any evidences in mind. Ram (Aryan God) never existed, it was total imaginary figure imposed on Dravidians who were original inhabitants of Bharat (India). Aryans were nomads and came to Bharat around 3500 years ago who were basically warrior and aggresive community. These facts have been rightly recorded by Archaeological survey of India. ASI doesn;t work on sentiments or emotion. This kind of agency are suppose to go by evidences, scientific proof and research. ASI has also confirmed Ganesha is also Aryan God, this Ganesha and Rama concept was bought by Aryans from outside. Myth= mithya. If you believe Ram then we can safely believe Spiderman , superman, He-man also to be future god, say after another 200 to 300 years. Ram, Hanuman are all mythological characters formed by Vaidic writers to be imposed on dravidians. By the way the word, Hindu, India is all terminology coined by Britishers. Hindu ism is a word or a common name of 1000s of small , tribal, regional religions of Bharat. Gods of South India are not known in North, and God of Assam are not known in Maharashtra. No wonder there are millions of mythological characters , deities in so called mythologically founded today’s Hinduism. Any person with right mind, with right sense will not believe these emootionally charged stories. Western historian and many non-brahmin, non-hindu historian wholly believe Ram and Ramayan has no historical evidences and no antiquity. I apologise for bringing the real facts. Truth must always win, not lies and stories.
0 Stars
Ramasamy
Sydney, Australia
THIS WILL REALLY STOP REAL RESEARCH IN INDIA. LET US CLOSE DOWN ALL THE SCIENTIFIC INSTITUTION, RESEARCH CENTRE, ISRO ETC. ASI is right, because they have to work in scientific manner, not with emotions , sentiments or myths. myths=mythology. Non existence of Ram and Ramayana characters were long known by many western historians. There are many books which are already published by various researchers. A book by title ” dravid Lineage” clearly indicates, there is no historicity or antiquity in Ram’s mythological story. If we believe in Ram then we would also believe spider man, superman as future gods. What a pity. Emotions rule science in country like India. This acts of suspension of ASI officers will certainly hamper any further authentic research in future. That case ASI required to be closed down for good because it will not have any truth from them in future. India has no place for honesty, truth. All that this country is ruled by goons. Close all the research institutions. Let us go back to Vanar age and live in jungle. Let us go back to Pajama and loongi culture and live in stone age , or vaidic age. Start preaching superstitions, myths, sathi pratha, snake tricks, child marriage, animal sacrfice. We Indians do not deserve science. No wonder we are still treated as country of goons and snake rope tricks.
0 Stars
Ramasamy
Sydney, Australia
I believe in everything !!! by bigfacts on Sep 21, 2007 11:21 AM | Hide replies I believe in everything: cheers 1) Krishna married 16008 girls and he was able to keep everyone happy and satisfied 2) Hanumanji lifted full mountain with his one hand 3) Monkey built the bridge over the sea 4) Saraswati married to Brahma , her own father 5) Ram and Ramayana is 400 million years old. 6) Draupadi married to five brothers ( looks like family incest) 7) Kauravs had 100 sons. 8) Kunti become virgin mother. 9) Ravan had 10 heads 10) A god has elephant face 11) A god has monkey face 12) Sacrificing animals (murdering) makes god happy. 13) Variety of war missiles used in Mahabharatha- astra , shastra. 14) Vishnu has so many avatars, Even Gandhiji, Albert Einstein, George bush are Vishnu’s avatar...LOL> 15)Brahma and his wife used to go out every day to create the world and all the things in it. 16)Agni is the son of his fatehr and his sister [ Rg Ved.I.91.7 ] Father-daughter incest occurs in the famous story of Prajapati (later identified with Brahma, in tunr incorporated as an incarnation of Vishnu) and his daughter [ RV III.31.1-2 ]. Pushan is the lover of his sister [ Rg Ved VI.55.4 ][ Apte 11 ] Now finally I agree and whole world believe that Ram sethu was created by Ram and Hanuman. We all belives these ... cheers...
0 Stars
Shankar
Jaipur, India
Sanskrit and Greek scholar and an expert on Hinduism Dr Bharat Gupt has demanded that Ram Setu be declared a cultural heritage site. ’'Whether Lord Ram actually existed or not is a needless debate. The Adam’s bridge or Ram Setu is so closely associated with our cultural moorings that it would be worth preserving it,’’ Dr Gupt told UNI. In this country, some people have an irresistible tendency to make a controversy out of everything, and trigger frivolous debates to create dissensions in the society, which would lead the country nowhere, he said. ’'And then we take a very limited view of scientific reason. Ram Setu is so much interwoven with the cultural history of Rameswaram and of the country as a whole that bringing the factor of the historicity of Lord Ram was absolutely unnecessary,’’ he said. Dr Gupt said personally he found no contradiction in the scientific explanation of the existence of Ram setu and the Hindu belief about its construction by the army of Lord Ram. ’'The setu is a natural formation. Fine. But can’t humans add to it. After all what they build is only an addition to what nature has already provided,’’ he would reason. It is sad to see that how in India people do not value their cultural heritage. In marked contrast to that, In the West even small sites like a lane associated with any cultural or historical figure is preserved and taken full advantage of from the point of view of tourism. People like bigfacts always do search the scientific proof before offering prayer to any God. This is ridiculous...
1 Stars
Vedika
mumbai, India
Who is God? For some he is the mind, the essence of all individuality. For others he is a myth, a concoction of the mind. Religion is the all inspirational force backing it all. What is this religion? Where did it come from? Who invented it? For millions of people across the globe, it is their faith that has led to the establishment of some of the greatest religions of the world.

First it was Satanic Verses by Salman Rushdie that created a sizzle in the religious world, then Da Vinci Code had the Vatican raising eyebrows and nowthe Ramsetu issue has religious heads bewildered. Greg Isles, in his best seller, The Footprints of God points out that God is all powerful. God is all good. Evil exists. You can logically reconcile any of those two statements but not all three.

Religious controversies sell, create a debacle, flare communalism and then fade away. What emerges strongest is ones faith in his belief. In a nation of billions, Lord Ram is a principle deity in every second home. The biggest festival of the year, Diwali, is celebrated to commemorate his victory over Ravana, the evil king of Lanka. The saga is recited over and over again, being passed down from generations. The teachings of the Ramayana form an integral part of our culture to respect ones parents and obey them. The family ties in India are known to be strong. Thus, to raise a question on the existence of God is to provoke antagonism in the minds of those who have been thriving on this belief.

Religion means everything to the people of India. It is a sin to raise question on the existence of Lord Ram. The sin has been committed by the Congress. Ram is everywhere. He dwells in the hearts and souls of his worshippers. It is insane to declare that he did not exist. These people are asking God to prove whether he is there or not. Why would millions of people pray to him if he was incapable of answering back?
0 Stars
Ramasamy
Sydney, Australia
Bad luck for Aryan gods: Well it is bad luck for Hindu country ( the hindu word itself was given by Britishers) Sonia Gandhi is catholic Man mohan singh is Sikh. Ex president abdul kalam is muslim Karunanidhi’s ancestors were Samanars( dravid version of ancient Jainism ) Gandhiji was half Jain. He never belived in Hinduism ( as Godse brother confirmed) Praveen Togadia is Jain who gave up Babri Masjid issue after ASI revealed that site belonged to Jain. Hindus (britishers named religion) have real poor luck...and historical disaster. South Indian hindu gods are not known to North indian hindus. and North Indian hindu gods are hated by dravids down south, which never existed in reality (only in brahmin stories). Hinduism is nothing but sad product of Brahmin lies today.Since all the Brahmin created Aryan gods are imaginary and artificial story characters.
Add your Comment