Shashi Tharoor’s candidature for the top UN job is facing opposition from fellow citizens for liaison with the controversial godman Sathya Sai Baba (SSB) and alleged obscurantism.
Members of Rationalist International, an Indian dominated forum for ‘rationalist ideas and positions of world-wide concern’ have asked for the withdrawal Tharoor’s candidature. The reason given behind this is that behind the suave and sophisticated intellectual image Shashi Tharoor sports lies a deviant mind that believes in the paranormal; and a great devotee of SSB, a godman who with sleight of hand and other organ grinder’s tricks managed to fool hundreds of thousands of people into taking him as God Incarnate.
Sanal Edamaruku, President, Rationalist International and President, Indian Rationalist Association has expressed his shock and dismay about India putting forward the name of Shashi Tharoor for the UN General Secretary’s post when Kofi Annan retires this year.
He says;
I am shocked to hear that the Government of India has nominated Shashi Tharoor as its candidate for the post of UN Secretary-General. Shashi Tharoor - despite his carefully nurtured image as a suave and balanced intellectual - is a hardcore propagandist of obscurantism, miracle-belief and all kinds of superstitions, who does not miss a single opportunity to raise his voice in the international media in favour of paranormal claims and in praise of godmen and miracle mongers.To corroborate his claims, Sanal Edamaruku has reproduced what Tharoor has written on his personal website expressing his position on India that reads -
In the 1950s, Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru declared dams and factories to be “the new temples of modern India.” What he failed to recognise was that the old temples continued to maintain their hold on the Indian imagination. The software programs of the new information technology companies dotting Bangalore’s “Silicon Plateau” may be the new mantras of India, but they supplement, rather than supplant, the old mantras. .... Saibaba and Infosys are, in fact, emblematic of an India that somehow manages to live in several centuries at once.
Not only this, Edamaruku has published a part of another of Tharoor’s writings about another such quack, this time a female, which reads as follows:
She took to standing in a crucified position, and blood appeared spontaneously on her hands and feet - the stigmata of Christian lore. Like Saint Teresa of Avila centuries earlier, she suffered seizures during which she levitated: neighbors would come to her family home on Fridays to see her suspended high against the wall in a crucified pose.In the end of the article, Edamaruku writes that should Shashi Tharoor become the Secretary General of the UN, it will cause major embarrassment to the country as “he is an articulate and avowed propagator of blind faith and superstition, and ridicules the scientific outlook of India’s policy, enshrined in the Indian Constitution”. Not only this, Tharoor as Secretary General would damage the reputation of the United Nations himself.
Now, this raises a deep and serious question. Should the man who devoted his youth through middle age to the cause of the United Nations and served it with distinction be subject to such harsh criticism? His own beliefs and practices never came in the way of his performance on the job he was entrusted with all his life.
However, on second thoughts, it does compel people like us to take stock of the man’s mind and his irrational beliefs. Those beliefs might not be a factor when dispensing duties, but then, charlatans like Sathya Sai Baba will get major boost with the patronage of such a high-profile figure such as the Secretary General of the United Nations.
The time is to move towards light from darkness, progress from backwardness and not take the world back to the dark ages of superstitions, blind beliefs and irrational practices.
I firmly believe that no matter whatever the credentials and the qualifications Shashi Tharoor might have, with a deviant mind, all the good work done by him might come to a naught in one stroke.
The Indian government must review its position on Tharoor seriously to save future blushes.
Report: Sai Baba EXPOSED





Comments
It is unfortunate that this site does not research the people whose blog posts are duplicated herein. The SaiBabaExposed blog belongs to Sanjay Dadlani. Unfortunately, there is no mention to Dadlani’s character. Far be it for Dadlani to be trying to expose Sathya Sai Baba when he has been fully exposed himself!
http://sanjaydadlaniexposed.blogspot.com/
Sanjay Dadlani Exposed
Joe,
No story has been duplicated here. Shashi Tharoor’s inclination towards quacks and the paranormal was out in the Hindustan Times on June 26. Before I blogged on this, the news was all over the mainstream media that rationalists are opposing Shashi Tharoor’s candidacy to the Secy. Gen. of the UN’s post.
I searched the blogosphere and found SaiBabaExposed had a good story on this with relevant links to the Rationalist International site where the president of the forum expressed his dismay. That has been properly linked here in the post as well.
UNESCO has shunned a body associated with the Sai Baba movement.
Why? Because of widespread reports of child abuse and molestation that was going on in the name religious practices.
When a body like the UNESCO does such a thing, it must be taken with utmost seriousness.
UNESCO is an UN body, Shashi Tharoor is a candidate for the Secretary General of the UN’s post and Shashi Tharoor is a devotee of the quack called Sathya Sai Baba.
So you can easily assess the kind of effect and repercussions the world body will have in the event a deviant like Tharoor is at the helm of the affairs.
Jonty, perhaps you failed to understand my comment. Since the ”report” link goes directly to Sanjay’s blogged entry about Tharoor (and not the original Rationalist International webpage) it is apparent you duplicated this post from Sanjay’s blog. Are you saying you did not duplicate this post from Sanjay’s blog? Then why is Sanjay’s blog used as the ”report”? Why didn’t you link the ”report” to the original webpage located on the Rationalist International site? It appears that you have a very strong and undeniable Anti-Sai Agenda and linked to Sajay’s blog to push that agenda. Unfortunately, you fail to realize what kind of person you are promoting.
And for your information, Unesco was swayed by Anti-Sai Activists propaganda. Anti-Sai Activists even boasted on how they accomplished it. Apparently you are unaware that Anti-Sai Activists have been attacking Unesco since Feb. 2005? Obviously, you need to do more research before you disseminate your slant and bias on these articles. Read the full story about the Unesco Withdrawal for yourself.
It is also revealing that you refer to Sathya Sai Baba as a ”quack”. Once again, you just made your bias and Anti-Sai Agenda fully known. Thank you.
Joe,
I read about the opposition to Tharoor’s candidacy in mainstream media. It was in the Delhi edition of Hindustan Times on 26th. I tried to search news on it over the net, but couldn’t find it even in the archives section of HT. I therefore, I did a blogsearch and found what I was looking for in SaiBabaExposed. Besides, I got the link to the Rationalist International site from SaiBabaExposed. Since I had to link a source, so it made a lot of sense to link the blog [which is the general practice in the blogosphere].
You are right! I have an anti-SSB agenda indeed. But to limit my anti-quackery agenda to SSB only will be a gross injustice to my cause - which is - to promote rational thinking and dissuade people from being done in by someone who produces cheap watches and fake jewelry out of thin air. I am against all godmen, tricksters and quacks who cheat people in the name of being associated with God. Not only SSB, I am against people like the ’miracle-man’ Benny Hinn etc., who unlike even the great Christian saints can perform a miracle in television, in front of large crowds within a snap of fingers!
If David Blaine and Sathya Sai Baba were to compete with each other in performing, Sathya Sai Baba would have to run to find a hiding place with his tail tucked between his legs.
The difference between Blaine and SSB is that he doesn’t proclaim himself to be god. Talent-wise, there is no comparison between Blaine and SSB. However, SSB exploited religion in a deeply religious country like India and have an army of brainwashed morons in his following.
As far as the UNESCO ban is concered and your reply is typical of a person suffering from ’True Believer Syndrome’. If not so, then other interests like commercial, carnal, political etc., might be a factor. In the SSB camp, all three things are prevalent.
It is such a disgrace that even in the 21st Century, there are some people who still believes such charlatans. A quack by any name is a quack, be it Sathya Sai Baba or Benny Hinn or the exorcists getting people rid of djinns and spirits in Delhi’s walled city.
Anyway, thanks for writing.
Jonty, why is it that atheists have such difficulty with the concept of ”freedom of religion” when they are allowed to practice non-religion themselves in the democratic society called India? If Tharoor can be denied a job simply because of his religious beliefs then so can YOU for being an atheist since many people consider atheists ”irrational” as you put it. My question is, why are atheists (the ”rational” police) involving themselves in an inquisition of those who believe in God? What purpose does it serve? Is someone funding atheists to attack Sai Baba?
While Sai Baba may be very controversial to atheists and evangelical Christians, he has NEVER been convicted of fraud or any other crime as you seem to imply by your extremely deceptive and devisive article. Fraud is an easy thing to prove in court if you have the evidence. So why are you giuys always on the internet beating your drums rather than the courtroom since you claim to have evidence of fraud?
On the other hand, in my almost four years of research into the allegations I have found evidence of crimes and wanted criminals within the anti-Sai activist group that is basically stalking and harassing Sai Baba and his followers.
I have turned information over to law enforcement EIGHT times as a result of my research. And that is JUST the tip of the iceberg.
My suggestion is that you leave the law enforcement to TRAINED professionals and find another way to become famous or whatever it is that motivates your kind.
Lisa De Witt,
It seems my words got lost on you completely. I am NOT against religion. I am a deeply religious and God-fearing man myself. So please come out of the notion that I am an atheist.
I am against quackery. Hence, I am against people like SSB. However, I am not against the fakirs and the sadhus who roam about all over the world.
My point is - what SSB had been doing in the name of religion and his proclaimed association with God (as if he is a special person, a human being above you and me and closer to God than me) is utterly despicable. With the help of a organ grinder tricks, showbiz and playing on the religious sentiments of people he amassed a huge following. Not only this, serious criminal allegations have been labeled against him including murders.
Let’s keep this thing simple. A ’high spirit’ like SSB doesn’t have to produce watches and jewelry out of thin air to impress devotees. That’s it.
Furthermore, you have all the freedom in the world to follow whatever religion or godman you wish, be it SSB or whoever he/she might me. I am not asking for your persecution. Neither, being followers of people like SSB is illegal. I respect your freedom of religion to the hilt. I just have a problem with people like SSB in the society that I live in. In my opinion, they are highly dangerous in senses more than one.
As far as Tharoor’s UN Secy. Gen. candidacy is concerned, well, I am not against him because of his religious beliefs, but because of his inclination towards the irrational, the paranormal.
I hope it clears your doubts about my stand here.
Like most of the anti-Sai activists, you seem to be a very confused person, Jonty. God’s very nature is ”paranormal” as you put it. Are you also against Jesus and his ”paranormal” healings? Do you consider God and Jesus ”irrational” because they exhibit paranormal qualities which may be beyond the present understanding of man? Do you also consider Krishna irrational?
Regardless of your protestations you are persecuting someone because of his religious beliefs (which include the paranormal). Lots of people have had paranormal experiences, so to me you sound rather irrational by trying to force others to abide by YOUR perception of what reality is.
Nobody is forcing you to believe in Sai Baba. But I seriously doubt you have the qualifications to judge someone you have never met. And I seriously doubt you have met either Sai Baba or Shashi Tharoor.
Are you aware that Mr. Tharoor has TWO masters degrees and a PhD, which he acquired at the age of 22, from Tuft’s University of Law? Mr. Tharoor has accomplished much more in his short span of life than you will probably EVER hope to accomplish.
**************
”Born in London, and educated in India and the United States, Tharoor received a doctorate and two masters degrees at the age of 22 from Tuft University’s Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy, says Reuters. His two sons are studying at Yale.
He is the author of nine books — three novels, a collection of short stories and five nonfiction books. His books include Reasons of State (1982), a scholarly study of Indian foreign policy; The Great Indian Novel (1989), a political satire; The Five-Dollar Smile & Other Stories (1990); a second novel, Show Business (1992), which received a front-page accolade from The New York Times Book Review and was made into a motion picture titled Bollywood; and India: From Midnight to the Millennium (1997), published on the 50th anniversary of India’s independence.
On August 13, 2001 Penguin Books (India) published Tharoor’s latest novel Riot. The US edition was published by Arcade on September 28, 2001. ”
*****************
From what I can see it is YOU who is being irrational, Jonty. You jumped onto the bandwagon of a dubious hate group that cannot back up their claims. They are not only irrational, but they are jealous and vengeful to boot.
So now we are getting to the heart of the matter. I wonder what religion you consider yourself since you have knocked out both the tenets of Christianity and Hinduism in one swoop. I seriously wonder at this point whether you are being truthful regarding your belief in God. Are you not aware that it was Hinduism (the oldest religion on the planet) that began teaching the ”I am God ” concept? Are you also not aware that even Jesus stated, ”I am God.’ That in fact ALL are God? So, once again, you prove you are persecuting Tharoor because of his religious beliefs which in reality have much more depth to them than your superficial mind is grasping. The truly wise man knows that he is the architect of his own reality. That his consciousness is, in fact, the creator of his own reality. Now obviously you do not believe this but you have no right to put others down because they do.
Both Jesus and Sai Baba are WORLD reknowned for their miracles (which are a DIRECT result of their understanding of the nature of consciousness) regardless of your ignorant protestations and deceptive propaganda. In the end, the ONLY one who will pay for his ignorance is you.
You are much more confused than you think you are. The fact that you THINK you understand something you obviously don’t is a testament as to your degree of confusion.
You do NOT understand Dr. Tharoor or his beliefs, PERIOD. You have not EVEN tried. Therefore you have NO right to judge him.
Dear Indiadaily.org and The Rationalist Internationals : Delighted to come across you by fluke ! I though I was alone in India ( with a few thousand others of my desperately successful OLD STUDENTS from schools where I taught or Headmastered / Rectored !).
I am proud of Shashi Tharoor and count him as a ’friend’, BUT we MUST NEVER allow anyone who surrenders his/her individual TOTAL RESPONSIBILITY for the false comfort of gods, religiouns, ’godmen’, gurus or any other false interlocutors !
I am disappointed in Shashi Tharoor, OF COURSE ONLY IN CASE HE DOES TAKE THE SATHYA SAI BABAS THE FIRST OR THE SECOND, SERIOUSLY ! Perhaps, like many of us lonely souls who try to be strong and alone, without crutches, he, too, was being ’playful’ or ’facetious’ with the Satya Sai Baba-types !
Glad this god me in touch with you !
Keep in touch, all of you !
HARI DANG, Padma Shri
MY SHORTCUT INFORMATION BELOW :
Wilderness-Equity® School – south of Gurgaon
The International Journal of Sustainable Development ®
Published by The Society for Technology and Action for Sustainable development, (TASD)
Quarterly Global Forum for Environmental Conservation and Equitable Development
Published by : Technology & Action for Sustainable Development
( Registered S-20355 under the Societies Registration Act. 1860 ) Exempt under 80 (G) and FCRA
India Wilderness-Tribal-Equity® International School(s)
The Indian School(s) of Excellence and Equity Sponsored by :
The (Third*) World Education Centre Society (TWECS)®
(Registered S-18293 under the Societies Registration Act. 1860) Exempt under 80 (G) and FCRA
Regd. Office: TASD at WILDERNESS HOUSE / DABUR HOUSE
# 1 Factory Road, adjacent western boundary of Safdarjung Hospital
New Delhi – 110029, India. Mobile: 9810743433
Telefax: 2619 8255; 2619 8954; 2616 3766; Direct: 26713879
From : Hari Dang Padma Shri [pro-tem Chairman, Board of Governors / Chief Editor]
THIS LETTER FROM : Residence and Chambers :
WILDERNESS EQUITY SCHOOL EDUCATION & SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT HOUSE
924, Sector 17-B, Gurgaon-122001, Haryana (NCR), India;
Telephones : 2342290, 2341014, Telefax : 4015433 ; Mobile:9810743433
From Delhi prefix 95124, from India prefix 0124, from outside India prefix 91-11 Email: wildernessequityschool@airtelbroadband.net; haridang@vsnl.com
Website : www.wildernessequityschool.org
* Chairman, International Himalayan Environment Programme and Action Projects Conference; United Nations International Year of Mountains, 2002; UN Year of Water 2003; Member, Governing Body, Automobile Association of Upper India; Founder-Member, Society for Urban Regeneration of Gurgaon and the National Capital Region, and the Indian National Trust for Art and Cultural Heritage (INTACH); Former Member, Central Advisory Board of Education (CABE), National Integration Council, National Commission on Teachers, National Children’s Board, Indian Board for Wildlife; Society for the National Institutes of Sports, Government of India (SNIPES); All India Council of Sports; Expert Committee on Infrastructure Development, Chairman/Convenor, sub-groups/committees on the Gulf of Kachchh in Gujarat, India; and Himalayan Heli-Skiing; Convenor, Society for the Conservation of the Delhi Ridge and the Yamuna (1970); Chairman, pro tem, The proposed India International School; President, The World Education Centre Society; Division of Elementary Education and Literacy, Indian Ministry of Human Resource Development Working Group on the 10th Five Year Plan; Honorary Chief Patron, The (Indian Education) Technology Mission; National Campaign for India (NCFI); National Network for India (NCNI); Consultant, Education Consultants of India Limited (Ed CIL).
Chief Editor, Quarterly International Journal of SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT; President-Chairman, The (Third) World Education Centre Society (TWECS); The India International School; Author of “HIMALAYAN ENVIRONMENT-Issues and Concerns of Conservation and Development”; “India’s New Education Policy”; “The Snow Leopard of the Himalayan and Its Prey; “Blueprint for School Education”; ”Timebound Total Literacy”; “Borderless Education:The Role of ITES”; “Gender Sensitivity in Education”; “The Vandalisation of India’s Wilderness since Independence”; and “India’s Heartland : Central Asia” (under preparation); President, Society for Technology and Action for Sustainable Development (TASD); Chairman, Centre for Development and Environment (CENDEVEN), Renuka Dang Memorial Drought Proofing & Desertification Research ; Woman and Child Development, Total Literacy ; and Sariska Tiger Conservation and Wilderness Centre, (at) Village (s) Jagannathpura/Narayani Mata and Roopu-ka-Bas, Tehsil Thana Ghazi, District Alwar, Rajasthan; Consultant, Education Consultants of India Limited (Ed CIL).
( HARI DANG ) Padma Shri